0:00
/
Transcript

3 Things Every Scene Must Do (Or It Doesn’t Belong) with Beth Barany and Gala Russ

A recording from Beth Barany's live video
Get more from Beth Barany in the Substack app
Available for iOS and Android

Here’s a summary of what we discussed plus more!

This material is adapted from Gala Russ’s Write Your Book class.

Point 1. A scene must change something

Most writers think a scene is “something happening.” I think of it as “something changing.”

Every scene is a before and after. If the reader can’t point to the difference, the scene isn’t doing its job.

  • What is the before? What is the scene question/goal?

  • What is the after? What’s different by the last line?

If nothing shifts, you can:

  • Eliminate that scene

  • Add a clear change

  • Combine with other scenes

Action for the writer

Analyze your scene: before and after.

Point 2. Every strong scene follows a cause-and-effect chain (Scene–Sequel Model)

Scene (external action):

Goal → what the character wants right now

Conflict → what’s in the way

Disaster → things don’t go as planned

Sequel (internal processing):

Reaction → emotional response

Dilemma → now what?

Decision → what they choose next

This creates a clean chain: action → consequence → meaning → next action.

Most writers skip the sequel—or rush it—and that’s why scenes feel either:

  • flat (no emotional weight)

  • or chaotic (no clear progression)

If your scenes feel disconnected, it could be because the decision at the end isn’t clearly driving the next goal.

Action for the writer

Analyze your scene: Is there an action and consequence?

Point 3. Strong scenes don’t resolve but escalate

An easy way to test escalation is to see if you can show if the character reached their goal by the end of the scene.

Use:

  • Yes, but… (success with a cost)

  • No, and… (failure that makes things worse)

This keeps:

  • Tension alive

  • Stakes rising

  • Readers turning pages

Scenes endings that keep the tension alive, stakes rising, and keep readers turning pages don’t resolve problems but make better, more complicated ones.

Action for the writer

Analyze scene ending for “Yes, but…” or “No, and…”


Connect with Gala Russ

Author • Book Coach • Publishing Strategist

Founder, Writing Conversations

Subscribe here and get notified about Gala’s monthly AMAs.

Gala helps creatives write their novels and build sustainable, values-aligned creative lives.

Email: galarussauthor@gmail.com

Location: California, USA (Pacific Time Zone)

www.galarussauthor.com


Subscribe to get notified for our weekly Lives.

Creativity Sparks by Beth Barany is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Share Creativity Sparks by Beth Barany

Beth Barany supports science fiction and fantasy writers in her member Edit Your Future membership. $5. Start with her free Edit Your Novel Checklist.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?